Shandrani or Heritage

We are in a dilemma as two travel companies are trying to persude us to either go to The Heritage, but the other travel agent is saying that it seems to have a small beach and two hotels bang next to it, but better food and activities or the Shandrani with less activities?

Please help if you have been to either of these Hotels with your comments?

Thanks

i dont know if this helps but out of the two its seems the shandrani is a top class hotel and it has 3 beaches,